When looking for fun things your kids can make with you potato salad is right up towards the top. They can not boil the potatoes or eggs obviously, but there are definitely things they can do. My kids love helping peel the potatoes after they boil because the skin comes off so easily. The older one peels the eggs and the youngest gets out a plastic knife and chops up the potatoes and eggs.
The potatoes and eggs are soft so no worrying about injuries and she gets to practice cutting and feel like a big girl. Who cares what the pieces look like it is potato salad after all not a gourmet meal. In the meantime I cut up the onions and celery. So many people just buy potato salad at the store but it is worth it to make your own.
You can make it however you want and have fun with your kids. Potato salad is touch and go when you buy it at the store. You get one and wish it had more eggs or another one that does not have enough mustard. When you make your own you can make it just how you want it. There is no wrong way.
What you will need
14 russet potatoes (you can also use red skin potatoes if you want and leave the peals on, just make sure you use more potatoes)
4 hard boiled eggs (We like more so we use 6 eggs)
onions (1/2 a small onion diced or split up between some white onions and some green onions.)
3 stalks celery diced
2 1/2 cups mayonnaise
1 Tablespoon yellow mustard (we add an extra tablespoon)
1/2 teaspoon white or black pepper
1 teaspoon salt
Before you begin you need to boil the eggs and potatoes. The eggs can be boiled ahead and refrigerated. It will be easier to peel them. I like to bring the eggs to a boil and then turn off the burner after one minute. Cover the pot and let sit for 20 minutes. This makes nice eggs that do not turn green. Boil the potatoes until they are fork tender. Drain pot and fill with cold water to cool them. When the potatoes are cooled you are ready to go. If you are using russet potatoes this is when you peel them.
Chop everything up and mix it in a bowl. That is it. Very easy and the kids get to help. If you want a fresh and crisp texture to the onions and celery then you can just chill it an hour and eat right away. If you like the flavors to get a chance to mix together then make it in advance. Often the second day it tastes the best. This is a great easy do ahead side dish. All you have to do is pull it out of the fridge and it is ready.
Variations
Remember that you can make it how ever you like it so have fun with it. Do you like more mustard or eggs? Do you like more onions? There is no wrong way to make it.
Often we add in bacon bits, but it HAS to be "real bacon" bacon bits not the weird stuff.
Some people like to add pickle relish, chopped up dill pickles, or bell peppers. I have not tried these because my kids would run the other way.
Deviled Egg Potato Salad
This may be my favorite way of making potato salad. I can not make it all the time though because if it is for the grandparents I have to leave out the spices.
For this twist you just have to mix 1 Tablespoon of paprika and 2 teaspoons of Tabasco sauce to the mayo before you mix it into the potato salad. Just enough spice.